Turing: Breaking Enigma Methodology (1939)
by Anonymous
Alan Turing chose to build an electromechanical machine (the Bombe) to crack Enigma rather than relying on purely mathematical analysis or captured codebooks. This automated approach could keep up with daily key changes.
Electromechanical Machine (Bombe)
1939-1940
year
Automated search through possible settings
approach
Could crack daily keys within hours
speed
Chosen — decoded thousands of messages, shortened war by years
outcome
Mathematical Analysis Alone
1939
year
Hand computation of key possibilities
approach
Too slow — key changed daily
speed
Insufficient alone — needed mechanical aid
outcome
Rely on Captured Codebooks
1939
year
Steal German code materials
approach
Fast when available, unreliable supply
speed
Used as supplement — not reliable enough alone
outcome
Like this comparison? Make it your own.
Sign up to use as templateMore in History
Spartacus: March on Rome or Escape Over Alps (73 BCE)
Stay in Italy and Fight vs Escape Over the Alps
Lewis and Clark: Northern vs Southern Route (1805)
Lemhi Pass (Northern Route) vs Direct Western Crossing
Britain: Appeasement vs Confrontation with Hitler (1938)
Appeasement (Munich Agreement) vs Military Confrontation
Bismarck: Social Insurance vs Laissez-Faire (1883)
State Social Insurance vs Laissez-Faire Capitalism vs Socialist Revolution
Hubble Space Telescope: Repair or Replace (1993)
Repair in Orbit (STS-61) vs Build Replacement Telescope vs Abandon Hubble
Isaac Newton vs Leibniz: Calculus Notation (1680s)
Leibniz Notation (dx/dy) vs Newton Notation (Dots)