Jenner: Vaccination vs Variolation (1796)
by Anonymous
Edward Jenner observed that milkmaids who caught cowpox were immune to smallpox. He chose to test cowpox inoculation (vaccination) rather than the riskier practice of variolation (inoculating with smallpox itself).
Vaccination (Cowpox)
1796
year
Very low — mild cowpox
risk to patient
Provided immunity to smallpox
effectiveness
Chosen — led to smallpox eradication in 1980
outcome
Variolation (Smallpox)
18th century
year
2-3% death rate
risk to patient
Provided immunity if survived
effectiveness
Replaced by safer vaccination
outcome
No Intervention
N/A
year
30% death rate from natural infection
risk to patient
N/A
effectiveness
Smallpox killed 300+ million in 20th century alone
outcome
Like this comparison? Make it your own.
Sign up to use as templateMore in History
Magna Carta: King John's Concession (1215)
Sign the Magna Carta vs Fight the Barons
Japan: Meiji Restoration — Modernize or Isolate (1868)
Rapid Westernization (Meiji) vs Continued Isolation (Sakoku) vs Selective Adoption
Bitcoin: Proof of Work vs Alternatives (2008)
Proof of Work vs Proof of Stake
Viking Settlement: Greenland Colonies (985 CE)
Settle Greenland's Fjords vs Return to Scandinavia vs Settle Further West (Vinland)
Hannibal's Route to Rome (218 BCE)
Cross the Alps vs Coastal March through Gaul vs Naval Invasion
Spartacus: March on Rome or Escape Over Alps (73 BCE)
Stay in Italy and Fight vs Escape Over the Alps