Channel Tunnel: Rail Tunnel vs Bridge (1986)
by Anonymous
After centuries of proposals, Britain and France finally agreed to build a fixed link. The choice was between a rail tunnel, a road bridge, or a combined bridge-tunnel. The rail tunnel won on safety and weather resistance.
Rail Tunnel (Chunnel)
1986
year
None — fully enclosed
weather impact
Trains carry cars, freight, and passengers
capacity
Chosen — opened 1994, 31 miles long
outcome
Suspension Bridge
1986
year
Severe — English Channel storms
weather impact
Cars and trucks directly
capacity
Not chosen — too exposed to weather
outcome
Bridge-Tunnel Hybrid
1986
year
Moderate
weather impact
Mixed
capacity
Not chosen — too complex and expensive
outcome
Like this comparison? Make it your own.
Sign up to use as templateMore in History
Penicillin Patent: Fleming's Choice Not to Patent (1928)
No Patent (Free for All) vs Patent It
Isaac Newton vs Leibniz: Calculus Notation (1680s)
Leibniz Notation (dx/dy) vs Newton Notation (Dots)
Wright Amendment: Protect DFW or Free Southwest Airlines (1979-2014)
Restrict Love Field (Wright Amendment) vs Open Competition
Caesar: Cross the Rubicon or Obey the Senate (49 BCE)
Cross the Rubicon vs Obey the Senate
Linux: Open Source vs Proprietary OS (1991)
Open Source (GPL) vs Proprietary (BSD-style or Commercial)
Britain: Appeasement vs Confrontation with Hitler (1938)
Appeasement (Munich Agreement) vs Military Confrontation