Wikipedia: Open Editing vs Expert-Written (2001)
by Anonymous
Jimmy Wales chose to let anyone edit Wikipedia rather than using credentialed experts (like Nupedia). Critics predicted chaos. Instead, the wisdom of crowds created the largest encyclopedia in history.
Open Editing (Anyone Can Edit)
2001
year
Crowdsourced, volunteer editors
editorial model
Explosive — millions of articles
growth rate
Chosen — 60M+ articles in 300+ languages
outcome
Expert-Written (Nupedia Model)
2000
year
PhD-level experts, peer review
editorial model
Glacial — 24 articles in first year
growth rate
Failed — became Wikipedia
outcome
Want to make your own version?
Sign up to create your ownMore in History
Abolition of the Slave Trade: Economic Pressure vs Moral Argument (1807)
Moral + Economic Argument Combined vs Moral Argument Alone vs Gradual Phase-Out
Montreal Protocol: Ban CFCs (1987)
Complete CFC Phase-Out vs Voluntary Reduction Targets vs No Action
Britain: Appeasement vs Confrontation with Hitler (1938)
Appeasement (Munich Agreement) vs Military Confrontation
Darwin: Publish Now or Wait (1858)
Publish Immediately (Joint Presentation) vs Continue Waiting
Magna Carta: King John's Concession (1215)
Sign the Magna Carta vs Fight the Barons
Bismarck: Social Insurance vs Laissez-Faire (1883)
State Social Insurance vs Laissez-Faire Capitalism vs Socialist Revolution