Lincoln: Fort Sumter — Reinforce, Abandon, or Resupply (1861)
by Anonymous
The newly inaugurated Lincoln faced a crisis at Fort Sumter. Reinforcing it meant war. Abandoning it meant recognizing the Confederacy. He chose to resupply (food only, no weapons), forcing the South to fire first.
Resupply Only (Food, Not Arms)
1861
year
Non-aggressive but firm
military signal
Union won't abandon federal property
political signal
Chosen — South fired first, North unified
outcome
Reinforce with Troops
1861
year
Aggressive
military signal
North as aggressor — lose border states
political signal
Not chosen
outcome
Evacuate the Fort
1861
year
Surrender
military signal
De facto recognition of Confederacy
political signal
Not chosen
outcome
Like this comparison? Make it your own.
Sign up to use as templateMore in History
Gutenberg: Printing Press Technology (1440)
Movable Metal Type vs Improved Woodblock Printing vs Continue Hand-Copying (Scriptoria)
Netflix: Streaming vs DVD-by-Mail (2007)
Streaming (Netflix Pivot) vs DVD-by-Mail (Status Quo) vs Brick-and-Mortar Rental (Blockbuster)
Spartacus: March on Rome or Escape Over Alps (73 BCE)
Stay in Italy and Fight vs Escape Over the Alps
Suez Canal: Route Selection (1858)
Direct Sea-Level Canal vs Indirect Route with Locks
WHO: Smallpox Eradication Strategy (1967)
Ring Vaccination (Surveillance + Containment) vs Mass Vaccination
Wright Amendment: Protect DFW or Free Southwest Airlines (1979-2014)
Restrict Love Field (Wright Amendment) vs Open Competition