Japan: Meiji Restoration — Modernize or Isolate (1868)
by Anonymous
After Commodore Perry forced Japan open, the country faced a choice: rapidly modernize along Western lines or resist foreign influence. The Meiji reformers chose radical modernization, transforming Japan in a generation.
Rapid Westernization (Meiji)
1868
year
Adopt Western technology, military, law, education
approach
Revolutionary — decades not centuries
speed of change
Japan became a world power by 1905
outcome
Continued Isolation (Sakoku)
1868
year
Maintain traditional society
approach
None
speed of change
Rejected — would have led to colonization
outcome
Selective Adoption
1868
year
Technology yes, culture no
approach
Moderate
speed of change
Attempted (wakon yosai) but full reform won
outcome
Like this comparison? Make it your own.
Sign up to use as templateMore in History
Internet Architecture: Packet Switching vs Circuit Switching (1969)
Packet Switching vs Circuit Switching
Ford: Assembly Line vs Craft Production (1913)
Moving Assembly Line vs Traditional Craft Production
Nuremberg Trials: Prosecute or Amnesty (1945)
International Criminal Trials vs Summary Execution (Morgenthau's Preference) vs General Amnesty
Apple: iPhone Touch Screen vs Physical Keyboard (2007)
Full Touch Screen (iPhone) vs Physical QWERTY Keyboard (BlackBerry)
Constantine: Adopt Christianity (312 CE)
Embrace Christianity vs Maintain Traditional Roman Paganism
Muhammad's Hijra: Stay in Mecca or Move to Medina (622 CE)
Migrate to Medina (Hijra) vs Remain in Mecca