Standard Oil Breakup: Regulate or Dissolve (1911)
by Anonymous
The Supreme Court ruled Standard Oil was an illegal monopoly. The choice was between heavy regulation (keeping it whole but controlled) or dissolution into competing companies. The breakup created the modern oil industry.
Dissolve into 34 Companies
1911
year
Break up monopoly into competitors
approach
Created ExxonMobil, Chevron, BP (Amoco), etc.
market effect
Chosen — defined antitrust law for a century
outcome
Regulate as Utility
1911
year
Keep whole but control prices and practices
approach
Government-supervised monopoly
market effect
Not chosen — trust-busting era favored breakup
outcome
Like this comparison? Make it your own.
Sign up to use as templateMore in History
Linux: Open Source vs Proprietary OS (1991)
Open Source (GPL) vs Proprietary (BSD-style or Commercial)
Y2K: Fix It Proactively or Wait and See (1995-1999)
Proactive Remediation vs Wait and Patch
Montreal Protocol: Ban CFCs (1987)
Complete CFC Phase-Out vs Voluntary Reduction Targets vs No Action
French Revolution: Constitutional Monarchy vs Republic (1792)
Republic (Abolish Monarchy) vs Constitutional Monarchy
Internet Architecture: Packet Switching vs Circuit Switching (1969)
Packet Switching vs Circuit Switching
Zheng He vs Columbus: Scale of Exploration (1405 vs 1492)
Zheng He's Treasure Fleet (China) vs Columbus's Expedition (Spain)