Magellan: Strait of Magellan vs Open Ocean (1520)
by Anonymous
Ferdinand Magellan's fleet spent 38 days navigating the treacherous strait at South America's tip. He chose this dangerous but shorter passage over sailing further south around Cape Horn in the open ocean.
Navigate the Strait
1520
year
Narrow, rocky, unpredictable winds
route danger
350 miles through strait
distance
Chosen — reached Pacific after 38 days in the strait
outcome
Round Cape Horn
N/A
year
Massive open ocean swells
route danger
Longer but open water
distance
Not discovered yet — Drake Passage found 1578
outcome
Turn Back
1520
year
Mutiny threat
route danger
Return to Spain
distance
One ship deserted; Magellan pressed on
outcome
Like this comparison? Make it your own.
Sign up to use as templateMore in History
Berlin Airlift: Supply by Air vs Abandon West Berlin (1948)
Airlift (Operation Vittles) vs Military Convoy Through Soviet Zone vs Abandon West Berlin
MLK: March on Washington Strategy (1963)
March on Washington vs Focus on Local Actions
The Crusades: Pope Urban II's Call to Arms (1095)
Holy Crusade to Jerusalem vs Send Military Aid to Byzantium vs Decline Byzantine Request
Britain: Appeasement vs Confrontation with Hitler (1938)
Appeasement (Munich Agreement) vs Military Confrontation
Y2K: Fix It Proactively or Wait and See (1995-1999)
Proactive Remediation vs Wait and Patch
Gutenberg: Printing Press Technology (1440)
Movable Metal Type vs Improved Woodblock Printing vs Continue Hand-Copying (Scriptoria)