Best Title Insurance Companies 2026

by Anonymous

Title insurance protects against ownership disputes, liens, and recording errors that could threaten property rights. A one-time premium of $1,000-$3,500 covers the life of ownership. The industry is dominated by four major underwriters that collectively handle 85%+ of all policies. Shopping between local agents of these underwriters can save 10-20% on premiums.

First American Title

~26%
market share
$1,000-$3,000
average premium
Yes (digital platform)
online closing
All 50 states
coverage area
Largest network, digital closings
best for

Fidelity National Title

~33%
market share
$1,000-$3,000
average premium
Yes
online closing
All 50 states
coverage area
Largest underwriter overall
best for

Old Republic Title

~15%
market share
$950-$2,800
average premium
Yes
online closing
All 50 states
coverage area
Competitive pricing
best for

Stewart Title

~12%
market share
$1,000-$2,900
average premium
Yes
online closing
All 50 states
coverage area
Personalized local service
best for

Like this comparison? Make it your own.

Sign up to use as template