Best Renters Insurance 2026

by Anonymous

Renters insurance protects your personal belongings from theft, fire, and other covered perils while also providing liability coverage. Most policies cost between $10-20 per month and cover far more than most renters realize. Landlord policies only cover the building structure, not your possessions. Additional coverage for high-value items like jewelry or electronics may require scheduled riders.

Lemonade

$5–$15
average monthly premium
$10K–$250K
personal property coverage
$100K–$500K
liability coverage
AI-powered, seconds
claims process
Yes, standard
replacement cost
Yes, with auto
bundle discount

State Farm

$12–$20
average monthly premium
$15K–$500K
personal property coverage
$100K–$500K
liability coverage
Agent or app
claims process
Yes, optional
replacement cost
Yes, up to 17%
bundle discount

Toggle (Farmers)

$5–$18
average monthly premium
$10K–$100K
personal property coverage
$100K–$300K
liability coverage
App or phone
claims process
Yes, optional
replacement cost
Yes, with Farmers
bundle discount

USAA

$8–$15
average monthly premium
$15K–$300K
personal property coverage
$100K–$500K
liability coverage
App, phone, or online
claims process
Yes, standard
replacement cost
Yes, with auto
bundle discount

Like this comparison? Make it your own.

Sign up to use as template